Friday, April 19, 2024
CommentaryMobile tech could expand equitable access in Ethiopia's financial services

Mobile tech could expand equitable access in Ethiopia’s financial services

Data from the Global Findex Database indicate that the percentage of adults with bank accounts in Ethiopia has more than doubled since 2014 to reach 46 percent. However, despite this growth, financial equity in the population has decreased. In particular, there are significant disparities in account ownership based on gender, income, and education.

As of 2022, women are 16 percentage points less likely than men to have an account, while adults in the poorest 40 percent of households face a 20-percentage point income gap. Additionally, there is a substantial education gap of 41 percentage points among adults with a primary education or less.

There’s also evidence that digital payments can increase an entrepreneur’s profitability by making financial transactions with customers, suppliers, and the government more convenient, safer, and cheaper. Even informal micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) can build a sales and credit history to improve their access to credit.

Yet in Ethiopia, 47 percent of self-employed adults have an account, as compared to 82 percent of wage workers (and 33 percent of adults who are out of the workforce).

Ethiopia falls behind its neighboring countries and regional counterparts like Kenya, Uganda, and Tanzania in terms of account ownership and usage. Not only is account access lower in Ethiopia, but usage rates, especially for digital payments, are also significantly lower. Only 42 percent of account holders—20 percent of adults—used their accounts for digital payments in the year prior to the Global Findex survey, far lower than the average digital payment adoption rate of 57 percent observed across all developing economies. Lower, even than regional peers like Tanzania, where 96 percent of account holders (50 percent of all adults) used digital payments.

- Advertisement -

Given the existing equity gaps, and how Ethiopia compares with regional counterparts like Kenya, Uganda, and Tanzania in terms of account ownership, what short-term opportunities exist to equitably increase account ownership and expand their use in the country? Our recommendations are to expand access to technology and increase the use of payment digitalization.

How technology access relates to account ownership

Account ownership in Ethiopia is predominantly tied to traditional financial institutions, such as banks, credit unions, and microfinance institutions, rather than mobile money accounts, which are more prevalent in countries like Kenya, Uganda, and Tanzania, and across sub-Saharan Africa as a whole.

In fact, only five percent of account owners have a mobile money account in Ethiopia, significantly lower than the sub-Saharan Africa average of 33 percent. Those who do have a mobile money account also tend to hold accounts with financial institutions, suggesting that Ethiopia faces unique barriers to reaching the unbanked with mobile money, in addition to more general account ownership challenges.

46 percent of adults in Ethiopia have an account, more than double the 22 percent in 2014.

Data show that, when asked about the reasons for not having a mobile money account, 51 percent of unbanked respondents reported not owning a mobile phone. (This finding is supported by Gallup World Poll data which indicated that only half of Ethiopians had a mobile phone.) Again, gender disparities are evident; 46 percent of women had a phone, compared to 57 percent of men.

Not having a mobile phone is a common barrier to mobile money account ownership in Ethiopia. Other commonly reported barriers to mobile money account ownership include the lack of necessary documentation for account opening (such as an ID or address verification), distance to mobile money agents, and the perceived costliness of financial services. Similar obstacles are mentioned when respondents are asked about owning accounts at traditional financial institutions.

How programs and policies that enable technology access and payment digitalization can drive account adoption and usage.

Addressing technological and infrastructural barriers to financial inclusion presents a crucial opportunity. Implementing programs that improve technological access and promote mobile money agent networks as a viable alternative to brick-and-mortar financial institutions, as seen in neighboring economies, could effectively reduce the barriers of distance, cost, and technological access, thereby increasing mobile money account ownership rates in Ethiopia to levels comparable to its neighbors.

Furthermore, digitalizing payments has been associated with improved account access and use. In developing economies, over a third of adults (half of all account owners) opened their first account in order to be able to receive a government payment or wage. However, in Ethiopia, only nine percent of adults (or one-fifth of account holders) did so, indicating low digital enablement by payers.

Nevertheless, there are indications that some payers are embracing the digitalization trend. In the year prior to the survey, one-third of adults receiving government payments did so digitally, surpassing the one-fifth share recorded in 2017.

Encouraging the adoption of digital payment methods can contribute to increased account ownership among unbanked adults. Similarly, there is potential for innovation in other payment types. Currently, only approximately five percent of adults who sell agricultural products receive their payments directly into an account—a rate that is unchanged since 2017. The remainder got paid in cash.

Embracing digitalization in a manner that allows payments to be sent directly to accounts, including to mobile money accounts, offers advantages for both payers and recipients. Governments and private sector payers have reported reduced costs, enhanced transparency, and fewer losses. Recipients, particularly the unbanked, benefit from a safer, more convenient way to receive their money and manage it.

Any efforts aimed at increasing financial inclusion must consider the financial capability of new users. Approximately, half of unbanked adults in Ethiopia state that they are unable to use an account independently. Therefore, ensuring that financially inexperienced adults can make use of such accounts for their benefit requires effective onboarding processes and product education, all in an environment that provides robust consumer protection measures.

Leora Klapper is a lead economist in the Finance and private sector research team of the development research group at the World Bank and Maroln Rolston is a financial sector specialist in the FIRST Initiative at the World Bank Group.

Contributed by Leora Klapper & Marlon Rolston Rawlins

[speaker]
- Advertisement -spot_img

Subscribe

- Advertisement -

Popular

More like this
Related

Cabinet Approves Transitional Justice Policy Despite Concerns

During a session today, the Council of Ministers approved...

‘Top secret’ talks underway to mediate Ethiopia, Somalia on MoU saga

Presidents Ismail Omar Guelleh and William Ruto are facilitating...

Investment board lays groundwork for trade business liberalization

Petroleum, fertilizer imports to remain off limits Under the leadership...

Ethiopia reinstatement uncertain as US senators push for AGOA reauthorization

Lawmakers in Washington are pushing a bill that would...